The Roundtable on Racial Disparities in Massachusetts Criminal Courts has released a new report, This Is What Thriving Communities Look Like: Insights from Residents of Four Boston Neighborhoods.
During the summer of 2022, we invited residents from four Boston neighborhoods â Roxbury and Dorchester, East Boston, and South Boston â to participate in focus groups organized separately into youth and young adults, parents of dependent children, elders, and formerly incarcerated residents to capture residentsâ diverse perspectives. Each focus group met twice, with each meeting spaced one week apart. During the first focus group session, residents shared their views on healthy and thriving communities and on public safety. At the end of this session, focus group moderators introduced residents to the photovoice method, a form of visual ethnography and a participatory research method that combines photography and narrative to center the perspectives of marginalized people and communities with the goal of effecting social change.
As residents left the first meeting, moderators invited them to respond to the following prompt using photographs: What does a healthy and thriving community look like or mean to you? One week later, during the second session, participants returned with photographs that responded to this prompt. The moderator then engaged residents in a conversation guided by and reflecting on their photographs. A few photographs are reproduced in the full report. Below are more of the photographs shared by the focus group participants.
And I think if we had cleaner, safer, nicer beaches, that it promotes a healthier life. It promotes togetherness as a family. And also, the water in itself releases stress. Itâs just all around a good environmentâŚI just think that when I see people at the beach, theyâre happy. Theyâre just enjoying themselves. Theyâre enjoying the sun. I think if we had cleaner beaches and safer beaches that would promote those things for the community. Their healing.âŻ
âJustice-Involved Resident of East Boston
I thought it was really interesting to see the stark difference between the luxury condos on one side and then you have the projects on the other side. And you see the police car is right on the other side.âŻAnd so, it shows what an unhealthy community looks like, to me. Thatâs why I took that one. I thought it was really interesting because it shows the stark difference between wealth income; I guess the priority that they might receive in terms of public safetyâŚand such a contrast of what East Boston maybe has been; sort of neglected, care-wise, for so long, and what it is sort of becoming â a center where people are investing more time in East Boston now.âŻBut itâs only now, after the sort of gentrification has taken off and when thereâs a lot more people of higher socioeconomic status. These parts are being remodeled, and these resources are being invested in, now. But there have always been people here in need of those resources.âŻâŻ
âEast Boston Young Adult
This was also at a work event. It was at Maverick LandingâŚThey had been taking digital literacy classes at Maverick Landing. But in this particular class, my team from workâwe came and gave a presentation about rent control, and the need that there is for rent control. Especially in East Boston. And especially in BIPOC communities. And we also gave a fast crash-course on their basic tenant rights. These are formally incarcerated people. One of them had actually said that they had just been released last week. And so, they are reintegrating into society and might not be aware of the rights that they have as tenants. And so, we wanted to give them those resources.
âEast Boston Young Adult
But I mean, I think a lot of what needs to be done is cleaning. I mean, I know we have street cleaning. But I feel like people ⌠I donât know how we can make people be more conscientious about the frigging trash they throw out.
I mean, I just go to my porch and I take a look out and Iâm likeâyou know what ⌠Iâm not sure if people know what âBeRealâ is. A lot of people are using it, kids my age. And we post âBeReal.â And Iâm like; okay, Iâm going to post my âBeRealâ of the day. And then Iâm like; this is a nice location, you know? And then you see trash floating. And Iâm like; you know what? Itâs no longer nice. I think my intention is to try to be like I wish it could be a cleaner area. Because I feel like that also attracts rats, and mice. I mean, I know the construction is whatâs bring out the rats a lot more, too. But also, leaving stuffâtrash and foodâoutside, it just sucks. And it brings a lot of insects, and roaches. And it just doesnât make East Boston or certain areas look nice. You know?
âEast Boston Young Adult
I put this on because I am just so inspired by how the entire exhibit is based around repurposing commonly used items. There are two different art displays, sculptures in the photo. In the back you can see a bunch of wooden cratesâand these wooden crates are like fruit and veggie crates that were repurposed into crates to hold supplies for workers that are in the shoe-mending industry.
This was in a different country; I think this was in Ghana. The artist took these crates and repurposed them into this sculpture. And then, right in front of it, as you all can probably tell â clothing. So, the artist took clothing from different areas where she found clothingâwhether it be in dumpsters, on the street, or in thrift stores, or from family and friends, and community membersâand used it to create this beautiful mosaic kind of quilt-like woven together clothing.
And I believe that this does a really great job at showing a healthy, thriving community, because it shows that ⌠and itâs making this art accessible to everyone to see that. First, it takes a village, and we are a part of a larger group of people. Weâre not just solely living in our own little bubble. So, I feel like these pieces reminded me of that. And, aside from the meaning of the pieces, I just love that this is free for people to come and see, and that it starts the conversation around how can we repurpose items that we were going to throw away and that could end up in landfills and stuff. And I thought it was really cool, making the art accessibleâbut then having a deeper meaning rooted in it around sustainability and just creating some type of awareness around waste, and what we can do with that waste to give it a new life.
âEast Boston Young Adult
[A]long those same lines of making art more accessible in communitiesâI took this photo on the greenwayâthe new greenway thatâs right by Airport Park. And I just loved how the music was being brought into not only this green space, but into East Boston; into an area where there are a lot of families and people that are hanging out, that are enjoying the day. And then they got to hear this music. For me, artâbut specifically musicâis so transformative and powerful. And I have seen it completely change peopleâs days around. And you could see when we were all walking by and people could hear these instruments, they were smiling, and they were curious. I think that really helps enrich a communityâŚBut the idea of putting art in public spacesâspecifically green spacesâactivates those environments and makes it easier for so many things to happen. For them to be advocated for, so that there is more upkeep of them and that more of those spaces exist. It helps people become more aware of the artist within themselves. And I just think it creates really positive experiences overall; so, it contributes to a thriving society.
âEast Boston Young Adult
I was doing some stuff for my college, and I just saw thisâŚ[T]here was that section, just a bunch of free chairs, and people can go sit down. There were people there earlier. It was just a nice area. The area is a bit bigger than what the picture shows. And there was an area to the side with tables, and stuff like that. I just really think itâs cool, because people can sit down with their friends or just sit down, and people can come up to them. They even had nets up. I donât know what type of nets, but you could play games. I thought that was really cool.
âEast Boston Young Adult
[T]hat was a building I attended when I was a kid; itâs called âEast Boston Social Centers.â When I went there, I was like nine years old. And every day we would have field trips. The group that I was in, it was intended for young children. Their parents dropped them off over there, and they would go on a field trip together.
It reminded me how there are these organizations that are meant for specific groups, like little kids. You go take a walk; you see kids in groups, with their red vests on. You know what Iâm saying? It reminded me of that.
The same with the YMCA. Thatâs another picture I have, of the YMCA in East Boston. Itâs these buildings and organizations that are meant for a specific group of people. Actually, not even specific groups; itâs for all groups, to be honest.
That just reminded me of how thatâs a thriving part of the community, because it brings people togetherâwhether youâre from different cultures, religions, ages.
âEast Boston Young Adult
Healthy communities. If you walk down my street, they are all like this. I love the flowers. The roses, everything. Theyâre clean, theyâre beautiful. And then you look up and you see the bars. I mean, theyâre trying. [E]verybody has to pitch in. Clean. Shovel your walkway. People didnât do that this year, butâ I donât know the word to use. Itâs not a contradiction, but itâs just ⌠some people are really trying. And then theyâre locking themselves in.
This one broke me. Where Iâm standing, you can see Iâm across the street. But at my feet thereâs syringe laying on the ground. Thereâs empty beer cans. Thereâs even more. But yet, right across the street there are all these kids and families having a great time. It killed me to see that. I loved everything across the street. But where I was standing, thatâs how close it is. Thatâs how it cuts right off. It could be just as far as right across the street; can be so much [good] going on. And then just being on the other side can be just the opposite.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Elder
This is Dorchester. This is at 2:05 pm, in the afternoon. And the street is empty. When I was a kid, at this time of day in the summertime, there would be kids out here playing jump rope, hopscotch, whatever. Itâs empty. And you said, âDonât take no pictures of people,â but there ainât no people there, anyway.
Then the next photo is a park. When I was a kid, that parkâat this time of day in the summertime and as hot as it was, there would be plenty of kids going up there to pay in the sprinklers, or the little baby pool, or whatever it is. You donât see anybody. This is 2:30 in the afternoon.
I just think that for me, my community is scared to come outside.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Elder
Thatâs a community center for kids to go to school there. Theyâve got a swimming-type classâŚAnd they do have a lot of activities for the kids, in the summertime. They have a nice little playground for the kids. Theyâve got some basketball courts. Theyâve got football fields built. You can walk around in the park. And they have a tennis center, which is located behind that a little bit. In that aspect, theyâre trying to make sure that the kids have a nice place to go in the summertime. Even in the wintertime, they can go in there and enjoy themselves. Because of what we talked about last week, about what theyâre doing in the community and stuff. And thatâs part of it right there. Which is good. Thatâs a real good thing that theyâre doing.
This is also part of the park. And at dusk, at night, thereâs a lot of illegal activities that go on over there. And thatâs the contrast of this park. In the daytime thereâs really not a lot of that activity going on. But at nighttime, it can get kind of rough over there. People go over there, they party. They do whatever they do. Part of this picture is them not cleaning up after themselves. Them not caring. People just not caring, period. And so, this is the contrast that I put together. Itâs one place, but there is so much going on in this one park. Daytime. Nighttime. Thatâs what those two photos are about.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Justice-Involved Resident
[T]hatâs a picture of someone thatâs locked up. And thatâs something that we fight for each and every day. My second picture kind of goes with that. Itâs a clemency campaign that the National Council for Incarcerated and Formerly Incarcerated Women and Girls held for Bidenâs first 100 days in office. We wanted to have him release 100 women. The âfree her clemencyâ campaign goes on in this state; they have a statewide clemency campaign, and the national council also works with them. So, every day this is what we fight for. The national council is also fighting legislation against prison-building, so we have the moratorium bill, which is the Senate Bill S2030. So, if anybody wants to go on and sign onto the moratorium; we want to stop the state from building more prisons. At least for five years. This is a group of women that fight for women, each and every day. I wanted to uplift that.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Justice-Involved Resident
So, I took a picture of a program in Dorchester. And itâs called âNew Beginnings Reentry Services for Women.â And itâs a brand-new program for women â by women, for women reentering out of prison. I think I said itâs a brand-new program. And the community has really given, believe it or not, the woman who started it a really hard time about being in this community. Which is surprising. They donât want the women here. They donât want them really coming out of the house. They want a curfew on the house. They donât want smoking. They donât want to see the women. They think itâs going to be all drugs, and prostituting, and itâs going to ruin their neighborhood. Which is really surprising, because we donât see the neighborhood as being amazing to begin with. We thought that this would be something that would really help the community thrive. So, [the woman who started it] is just going forward with her plans to try and make it.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Justice-Involved Resident
And this was me just driving through Cambridge. Iâm admiring all the green, right? Again, you have permit parking here where there are residential homes. And thereâs not so many trees, but ⌠Well, there are so many trees, actually, for a city. This is very different, compared to Boston. You could breathe. You could walk through here safely, without being afraid that you're going to get shot, or even racially profiled.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Justice-Involved Resident
And the next one is right here in my neighborhood. This is outside of my apartment building. I can say itâs pretty safe, because a lot of community members hang out. Theyâre out there now. Theyâre out there playing dominoes. Theyâre playing a little bit music over there. The kids run around out here and play. So, itâs not really bad. I donât sit out there often, because Iâm always doing stuff. But when I do get a chance, itâs pretty nice. I can say that.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Justice-Involved Resident
Thatâs a backyard, an area that my kids play in. I feel like thatâs what our kids should be playing in; a nice, clean backyard. Because there are some other backyards near us that are real filthy and dirty. Thatâs the backyard my kids play in. I just feel safer with them in that backyard than a lot of the kids. This is near my momâs house.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Justice-Involved Resident
I see a business supporting the LGBQT community. And I feel like in most areas thatâs kind of big, because it lets people know that youâre not biased towards them, and that youâre open towards anybody. Because most areas you wonât even see anything that has to do with the flag, really. So, itâs kind of a rare thing you see. I feel like a community thatâs open to anything is thriving. They have an advantage, because everybody has a growth mindset. Theyâre not small-minded. For me, I feel like itâs a good example of a thriving community.
âRoxbury-Dorchester Young Adult
But the benches, and that open space, and that sense of welcoming means that theyâre thinking about people; theyâre not just thinking about ⌠thereâs a humanity in that, that is very important. Then they have little trees. So, they are also thinking about the climate, you know? And good thought and good thinking went into that, to make it a good open space for people to enjoy. And I think thatâs very important. And having new buildings that are up-to-date, and are clean, and service so many people; itâs very important. So, the new structures, but also the thought. The human element was thought about when they were designed and itâs placed on this space. Itâs very important.
âSouth Boston Elders
Thatâs a school. If you have a school in the community, then you have the kids that go to school in the community. So, they try to keep it clean. You see laughter. You see growth, development. You also have outside people that come into the community and help the community; such as the teachers, priests, police officers, fire department guys, army people. So, itâs all about bringing the community together and keeping it strong. I feel a school is a very vital part in a great community.
âSouth Boston Justice-Involved Resident
[Y]ou need a church to be striving. You know, so the people in the community go to the church. Theyâre part of the community. And it just brings about a different aspect of life. Itâs like a safe zone for kids. They incorporate different functions, different trips. They have bible study, childrenâs bible study. They have things that a community could come together and share and become wholeâand tap into something outside of themselves. Something greater than themselves.
âSouth Boston Justice-Involved Resident
Thatâs the new projects, basically after theyâve been remodeled or whatever. But I noticed a change in the community. Back in the days, we hung there, hard. Everybody went up there. It was a hangout, the neighborhood hangout. But at the same time, no one really took care of it. Because it was a run-down brick building, projects from the â40s - â50s. Just the neighborhood I guess made people not even want to take care of it. So, we would just leave beer bottles all around, and trash all around. Have a cookout, and just leave everything dispersed all around. Now, I noticed that ever since they rebuilt everything, itâs sort of like the community came together. Because I guess the environment is better, so people want to actually step in and help out to take care of it. So, we are actually a product of our environment in that senseâŚjust because our environment changed and itâs a lot cleaner, and everybody ⌠they appreciate where theyâre living, now. Thereâs trash bags now, for the beer bottles. And people go outside and sweep up. I donât know. Itâs just a big change. I noticed that.
âSouth Boston Parent